| Event Name | Date Played | Black Pieces | White Pieces | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | McKelvie, D.G. | Gardner, W. | Black Wins |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | McKelvie, D.G. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | McKelvie, D.G. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | McKelvie, D.G. | White Wins |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | McKelvie, D.G. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | McKelvie, D.G. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Campbell, W.K. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Campbell, W.K. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Campbell, W.K. | Gardner, W. | Black Wins |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Campbell, W.K. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Campbell, W.K. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Campbell, W.K. | White Wins |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Young, J. | Black Wins |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Young, J. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Scotland v England 1884 | 1884-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Young, J. | Draw |