| Event Name | Date Played | Black Pieces | White Pieces | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Strickland, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Strickland, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Strickland, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Strickland, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Strickland, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Gardner, W. | Strickland, W. | Draw |
| Leeds 1886 | 1886-??-?? | Strickland, W. | Gardner, W. | Draw |
| Providence 1886, game 1 | 1886-??-?? | Barker, C.F. | Heffner, A.J. | Draw |
| Practice match 1886, game 1 | 1886-??-?? | Smith, J. | Richmond, J.L. | Draw |