| Event Name | Date Played | Black Pieces | White Pieces | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carlisle 1861, game 11 | 1861-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | Black Wins |
| Carlisle 1861, game 12 | 1861-??-?? | Tonar, J. | McMillan, J. | Black Wins |
| Carlisle 1861, game 13 | 1861-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | White Wins |
| Carlisle 1861, game 14 | 1861-??-?? | Tonar, J. | McMillan, J. | Draw |
| Carlisle 1861, game 15 | 1861-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | Black Wins |
| Carlisle 1861, game 16 | 1861-??-?? | Tonar, J. | McMillan, J. | Draw |
| Carlisle 1861, game 17 | 1861-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | White Wins |
| Carlisle 1861, game 18 | 1861-??-?? | Tonar, J. | McMillan, J. | Black Wins |
| Carlisle 1861, game 19 | 1861-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | White Wins |
| Newcastle 1863, game 1 | 1863-??-?? | Grant, B. | Fletcher, T. | Draw |
| Carlisle 1863, game 1 | 1863-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | White Wins |
| Newcastle 1863, game 2 | 1863-??-?? | Fletcher, T. | Grant, B. | Black Wins |
| Carlisle 1863, game 2 | 1863-??-?? | Tonar, J. | McMillan, J. | Draw |
| Newcastle 1863, game 3 | 1863-??-?? | Grant, B. | Fletcher, T. | Draw |
| Carlisle 1863, game 3 | 1863-??-?? | McMillan, J. | Tonar, J. | Draw |